Check out additional Server StorageIO Tips & Articles here along with commentary in the news here

More Storage IO momentus HHDD and SSD moments part I

April 29, 2012 – 11:54 am

This is the first of a two part series on my latest experiences with HHDD and SSD’s

About two years ago I wanted to start installing solid state devices (SSD’s) into my workstations and laptops. Like many others, I found the expensive price for the limited capacity gains of the then generation SSD’s did not make for a good business decision based on my needs. Don’t get me wrong, I have been a huge fan of SSD for decades as an IT user, vendor, analysts, consultant and consumer and still am. In fact I have some SSD’s used for different purposes as well as many Hard Disk Drives (HDD) and Hybrid Hard Disk Drives (HHDD’s). Almost two years ago when I first tested the HHDD’s, I did an first post in this ongoing series and this two-part post is part of that string of experiences observed evolving from HDD’s to HHDD’s to SSD’s

Seagate Momentus XT Hybrid Hard Disk Drive (HHDD) with SSD
Image courtesy of Seagate.com

As a refresher, HHDD’s like the Seagate Momentus XT combine a traditional 7,200 RPM 2.5 inch 500GB or 750GB HDD with an integrated single level cell (SLC) nand flash SSD within the actual device. The SSD in the HHDD’s is part of the HDD’s controller complementing the existing DRAM buffer by adding 4GB (500GB models) or 8GB (750GB models) of fast nand flash SSD cache. This means that no external special controller, adapter, data movement or migration software are required to get the performance boost over a traditional HDD and the capacity above a SSD at an affordable cost. In other words, the HHDD’s bridge the gap between those who need large capacity and some performance increases, without having to spend a lot on a lower capacity SSD.

However based on my needs or business requirements two years ago I found the justification to get all the extra performance of  SSD not quite there when. Back two years ago my thinking was that it would be about two maybe three years before the right point for a mix of performance, availability (or reliability e.g. duty cycles), capacity and economics aligned.

Note that this was based on my specific needs and requirements as opposed to my wants or wishes (I wanted SSD back then, however my budget needed to go elsewhere). My requirements and performance needs are probably not the same as yours or others might be. I also wanted to see the incremental technology, product and integration improvements ranging from duty cycle or program/erase cycles (P/E) with newer firmware and flash translation layers (FTLs) among other things. Particularly with multilevel cell (MLC) or enhanced multilevel cell (eMLC) which helps bring the cost down while boosting the capacity, I’m seeing enough to have more confidence in those devices. Note that for the past couple of years I have used single level cell (SLC) nand flash SSD technology in my HHDD’s, the same SSD flash technology that has been found in enterprise class storage.

While I wanted SSD’s two years ago in my laptops and workstations to improve productivity which involves a lot of content creation in addition to consumption, however as mentioned above, there were barriers. So instead of sitting on the sidelines, waiting for SSD’s to either become lower cost, or more capacity for a given cost, or wishing somebody would send me some free stuff (that may or may not have worked), I took a different route. That route was to try the HHDD’s such as Seagate Momentus XT.

Seagate Momentus XT and goflex cable, image via StorageIO.com

Disclosure: Seagate sent me my first HHDD for first testing and verifications before buying several more from Amazon.com and installing them in all laptops, workstations and a server (not all servers have the HHDD’s, or at least yet).

The main reason I went with the HHDD’s two years ago and continue to use them today is to bridge the gap and gain some benefit vs. waiting and wishing and talking about what SSD’s would enable me to do in the future while missing out on productivity enhancements.

The HHDD’s also appealed to me in that my laptops are space constrained for putting two drives and playing the hybrid configuration game of installing both a small SSD and HDD and migrating data back and forth. Sure I could do that for in the office or carry an extra external device around however been there, done that in the past and want to move away from those types of models where possible.

Related links on SDD, HHDD and HDD
More Storage IO momentus HHDD and SSD moments part I
More Storage IO momentus HHDD and SSD moments part II
IO IO it is off to Storage and IO metrics we go
New Seagate Momentus XT Hybrid drive (SSD and HDD)
Other Momentus moments posts here here, here, here and here
SSD and Storage System Performance
Speaking of speeding up business with SSD storage
Are Hard Disk Drives (HDD’s) getting too big?
Has SSD put Hard Disk Drives (HDD’s) On Endangered Species List?
Why SSD based arrays and storage appliances can be a good idea (Part I)
Why SSD based arrays and storage appliances can be a good idea (Part II)
IT and storage economics 101, supply and demand
Researchers and marketers dont agree on future of nand flash SSD
EMC VFCache respinning SSD and intelligent caching (Part I)
EMC VFCache respinning SSD and intelligent caching (Part II)
SSD options for Virtual (and Physical) Environments Part I: Spinning up to speed on SSD
SSD options for Virtual (and Physical) Environments Part II: The call to duty, SSD endurance
SSD options for Virtual (and Physical) Environments Part III: What type of SSD is best for you?
SSD options for Virtual (and Physical) Environments Part IV: What type of SSD is best for your needs

Ok, nuff said for now, lets resume this discussion in part II.

Cheers Gs

Greg Schulz – Author Cloud and Virtual Data Storage Networking (CRC Press, 2011), The Green and Virtual Data Center (CRC Press, 2009), and Resilient Storage Networks (Elsevier, 2004)

twitter @storageio

All Comments, (C) and (TM) belong to their owners/posters, Other content (C) Copyright 2006-2012 StorageIO and UnlimitedIO All Rights Reserved

  1. 20 Trackback(s)

  2. Apr 29, 2012: More Storage IO momentus HHDD and SSD moments part II | StorageIOblog
  3. Apr 30, 2012: More Storage IO momentus HHDD and SSD moments part II « Data-Center.BlogNotions - Thoughts from Industry Experts
  4. May 2, 2012: More Storage IO momentus HHDD and SSD moments part 11 - StorageIO Blog - IBM Storage Community
  5. Sep 27, 2012: Cloud, virtualization, storage and networking in an election year - StorageIO Blog - IBM Storage Community
  6. Nov 12, 2012: Have SSDs been unsuccessful with storage arrays (with poll)? | StorageIOblog
  7. Nov 13, 2012: Have SSDs been unsuccessful with storage arrays (with poll)? - StorageIO Blog - IBM Storage Community
  8. Nov 13, 2012: Have SSDs Been Unsuccessful With Storage Arrays? | Egypt
  9. Nov 26, 2012: The Data Center Journal Have SSDs been unsuccessful with storage arrays (with poll)?
  10. Jan 11, 2013: The Data Center Journal The Human Face of Big Data, a Book Review
  11. Jan 21, 2013: Putting some VMware ESX storage tips together (Part I) | StorageIOblog
  12. Jan 28, 2013: The Data Center Journal Putting some VMware ESX storage tips together
  13. May 21, 2013: The Human Face of Big Data, a Book Review | StorageIOblog
  14. May 23, 2013: Part II: XtremIO, XtremSW and XtremSF EMC flash ssd portfolio redefined | StorageIOblog
  15. Jul 16, 2013: Can we get a side of context with them IOPS and other storage | StorageIOblog
  16. Jul 17, 2013: Can we get a side of context with them IOPS and other storage metrics? - StorageIO Blog - IBM Storage Community
  17. Jul 23, 2013: As the platters spin, HDD's for cloud, virtual and traditional storage environments - The Data Center Journal
  18. Jul 26, 2013: Can we get context with them IOPS and other metrics? - The Data Center Journal
  19. Aug 4, 2013: As the platter spins, HDD's for cloud, virtual and traditional storage environments | StorageIOblog
  20. Apr 9, 2014: Upgrading Lenovo X1 Windows 7 with a Samsung 840 SSD - StorageIOblog
  21. May 30, 2014: Nand flash SSD server storage I/O conversations

Post a Comment

Powered by Disqus